I was upset that 4 people voted to close Godels Incompleteness Theorem(s) and Consciousness is Non Algorithmic as off-topic, by clicking an option that totally dismisses the question, rather than trying to help the new-user by recommending a place for migration.
This question should get at least get a chance at Philosophy SE or maybe Mathematics. When voting to close I clicked "off-topic" then "migration", but the only option was to migrate to Meta:
Shouldn't we also provide the options to migrate to:
- CS
- Physics
- Chemistry
- Biology
- Cross-Validated
- Philosophy
- Mathematics
- MathOverflow
?
It is not a good thing when a question gets voted to be "closed" but for a reason that does not make any sense.
On ChemistrySE I had this question closed as "too broad":
But it was razor specific. Not "broad" at all. So I can accept that the chemistrySE community felt it was not appropriate, but the reason they gave did not make sense, and less experienced users might have taken that in a worse way than I did.